Showroom inside Preferred EyeCare
Preferred EyeCare - New Castle

Your New Castle Eye Doctor

On the corner of 14th and Washington Street near Henry County Hospital

Schedule an Exam Today

About Preferred EyeCare - New Castle

At Preferred Eye Care, our eye care services go beyond routine check-ups. We offer unparalleled skill and patient-centered service for visual acuity tests, comprehensive exams, contact lens fittings, stylish eyeglasses, and expert treatment for eye diseases and conditions. Preferred Eye Care serves Central Indiana from three convenient locations in Marion, Kokomo, and New Castle.

Our staff is fluent in English and Spanish, making communicating with people from different walks of life easy. Preferred Eye Care also accepts Insurance plans to help you cover the cost.

Schedule Eye Exam

Outside Preferred EyeCare



Meet our Eye Doctor

Patient Reviews
4.8
233 Reviews
5
4
3
2
1
- Sep. 28, 2023
Always friendly and Contact order to delivery is always faster than predicted. Dr.Jessica is very n... ice and listens.
- Jan. 05, 2024
This was my first visit, and I was treated very courteously. Dr. Kieninger did a thorough exam and I... am confident in her diagnosis. Even printed me a Good RX coupon. I couldn't ask for anything more.

View All 233 Reviews

Our Eye Care Services

Other Services

Eye emergencies such as severe pain in the eye, or foreign objects puncturing the eye require immediate attention. Contact us immediately.

View Emergency Eye Care

Clear vision is an essential part of a child’s healthy development and learning. Regular pediatric eye exams can help detect and treat common issues.

View Pediatric Eye Care

Eye diseases such as glaucoma and macular degeneration can cause severe loss of vision if not diagnosed and treated early. Our eye care team can help.

View Eye Disease Management

LASIK and refractive surgery are great ways to say goodbye to contacts and glasses for good. Find out if you’re a good candidate.

View LASIK Co-Management

Astigmatism can cause vision problems such as blurred or double vision at all distances. Find out what you can do to correct astigmatism and see your best.

View Astigmatism Treatment

Macular degeneration can cause severe central vision loss if not detected and treated early on. We can help preserve your vision.

View Macular Degeneration

Over 50% of people living with glaucoma don’t know they have the disease as it shows no symptoms. Early detection and treatment can prevent blindness.

View Glaucoma Treatment

The ups and downs of diabetes can be difficult to navigate. How can diabetes affect your eyes? How can you and your eye doctor keep them healthy?

View Diabetic Retinopathy

Presbyopia is a normal part of aging. If you’re past 40 and notice you can’t read up close, our eye doctors may be able to help.

View Presbyopia Treatment

While vision can change drastically in the senior years, these changes shouldn't have to impair one's quality of life. The earlier these problems are detected and treated, the more likely proper eye care can help you retain good vision.

View Senior Vision

Low vision occurs when a person’s visual acuity is 20/70 or worse, and their vision can’t be fixed with glasses or contacts. Find out how an eye doctor can help.

View Low Vision


Eyeglasses & Frames

Designer Frames

Designer Frames

Our extensive optical section offers a wide variety of eyeglass frames in every style, material & design. Come visit us today to see for yourself!

Our expert optical team can find just the right pair of glasses for you to be confident and look your best.

View Sunglasses

Lens coatings improve visual comfort, make it easier to clean your glasses and ensure your lenses last longer. Coatings include anti-scratch, anti-reflective, photochromatic and UV / blue light filters.

View Lens Treatments

Contact Lenses

Order Contacts

Contact Lens Fitting

We offer a wide range of contact lens options from dailies, monthly to multifocal contact lenses for crystal clear vision and superior comfort.

During a contact lens exam, your eye doctor will check if you are a good candidate for contacts and find the best type of contacts for your needs.

View Eye Exams for Contact Lenses


New Year, New Benefits!
New Year, New Benefits!

Buy One, Get One 50% Off Complete Eyeglasses

*Requires purchase of a complete prescription pair, including frame and lenses at regular price. Discount applied to additional complete pairs of equal or lesser value. Does not include Barton Perreira, Cartier, Cazal, Chanel, Cutler and Gross, Dior, Dita Lancier, Fendi, Gucci, ic!Berlin, l.a. Eyeworks, Maui Jim, Michael Kors, Nifties, Oakley, Oliver Peoples, Persol, Ray-Ban, Robert Marc, Silhouette, Tiffany & Co., Tom Ford, WOOW, accessories, contact lenses, or medical procedures. Cannot be combined with any other discounts, promotions, or insurance plans. Not valid on previous orders. Other restrictions may apply. See practice for full details. Offer valid 01/01/2024-03/17/2024. 24AEG-682100

View Promotions


We Accept Most Insurance Plans

Insurance Questions

Have another plan?
Benefit questions?
Paying out of pocket?
Call us, we are happy to help.

(765) 529-9364

VSP logo
VSP
Medicare logo
Medicare
United Healthcare logo
United Healthcare
Aetna logo
Aetna
Cigna logo
Cigna
Spectera logo
Spectera
Superior Vision logo
Superior Vision
Davis Vision logo
Davis Vision
EyeMed logo
EyeMed
Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield logo
Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield


Location & Opening Hours

On the corner of 14th and Washington Street near Henry County Hospital

  • Download more icon variants from https://tabler-icons.io/i/moon Open Evenings
  • Download more icon variants from https://tabler-icons.io/i/parking Onsite Parking
  • Download more icon variants from https://tabler-icons.io/i/car Free Parking
  • Download more icon variants from https://tabler-icons.io/i/wheelchair Wheelchair Accessible
  • Download more icon variants from https://tabler-icons.io/i/wifi Free Wifi
Business Hours
  • Monday 8:30 am - 7:00 pm
  • Tuesday 8:30 am - 4:00 pm
  • Wednesday 8:30 am - 4:00 pm
  • Thursday 8:30 am - 4:00 pm
  • Friday 8:30 am - 1:00 pm
  • Saturday Closed
  • Sunday Closed